Librecast Incident Response

Be sure to have a good understanding of our Code of Conduct, which can be found here:

Also have a good understanding of what is expected from an participant that wants to report an incident. These guidelines can be found here:

• https://librecast.net/policies/reported-coc.html

When taking an incident report:

1. Be an active listener and don’t use judgement words
2. Ensure the reporter’s safety
3. Take down the report and ask any clarifying questions
4. Thank the reporter for reporting the incident

While gathering information from the reporter:

1. Do not invite them to withdraw the incident report
2. Do not ask for their advice on how to immediately respond to the incident
3. Do not offer them input into the long-term response to the incident
4. Do not promise any particular response, since it may differ from the official response.

Try to get as much of the incident in written form by the reporter. If you cannot, transcribe it yourself as it was told to you. The important information to gather include the following:

• Current date and time
• Date and time of the incident
• Location of incident
• Description of the incident
• Identifying information of the reported person
• Additional circumstances surrounding the incident
• Reporter’s name and contact information. If the reporter wants to make an anonymous report, allow them to do so. If responding to the incident would reveal who reported the incident (e.g. a microaggression in one-on-one conversation) ask the reporter if they have safety concerns about this.
• Other people involved in or witnesses to the incident and their contact information or description
• Do not prompt the reporter for suggestions of how to handle the incident, but record their suggested responses if they offer them

Assess whether an immediate response is necessary. This initial response is very important. Depending on the severity/details of the incident, please follow these guidelines:

• If there is any general threat to attendees or the safety of anyone.
• If everyone is presently physically safe, involve law enforcement or security only at a reporter’s request.
• After taking the report, assess whether you need to immediately respond to the incident.

Respond to reporter needs. You can:

• Thank the reporter for making the incident report
• Reassure them that the incident report will be reviewed by the lead incident moderators
• Gather their contact information to send a follow-up after the incident is resolved
• Ask them, “How else can I help?”

Once something is reported, the COC moderators should meet. The main objectives of this meeting is to:

• Review report documentation to determine what happened
• Consult documentation of past incidents for patterns of behavior
• Discuss appropriate response(s) to the incident
• Assign a person to make those reponse(s)
• Determine the follow up actions for any impacted people and/or the reporter
• Assign a person to follow up with the impacted people

After the meeting and discussion, the COC moderator may choose to communicate with the reported person.

When following up with a reported person:

• Explain what happened
• Focus on the impact of their behavior
• Reiterate the Code of Conduct and that their behavior was not appropriate
• Give them concrete examples of how they can improve their behavior
• Remind them of the consequences of their behavior, or future consequences if the behavior is repeated

People who are reported often get upset, defensive, or deny the report. Allow them to give any additional details about the incident. However, remember:

• It does not matter if they did not intend to hurt anyone – their behavior still impacted attendees negatively
• It is not your job to reassure or forgive them
• Do not allow the reported person to make an apology to the reporter or impacted person. Often an apology centers the reported person’s feelings and not the person who was impacted. You may accept their apology and offer to pass it on (but you’re not required to if you think it would negatively impact the reporter).

What follows are examples of possible responses to an incident report. This list is is not inclusive, possible responses to an incident include:

• Nothing, if the behavior was determined to not be a Code of Conduct violation
• A verbal or emailed warning
• Requiring that the reported person avoid any interaction with the reportee (either indefinitely or for a certain time period)
• Immediately ending any event volunteer responsibilities and privileges the a person holds
• Requiring that a person not volunteer for future events (either indefinitely or for a certain time period)
• Banning a person from all Librecast spaces (either indefinitely or for a certain time period)
• Removing a person from membership of relevant organizations
• Publishing an account of the incident and (optionally) calling for the resignation of a person from their responsibilities

If a reported person wants to appeal the decision, notify them that they may appeal. Keep in mind that it is not a good idea to encourage an apology from the reported person.

It is very important to consider how we deal with the incident publicly. Our policy is to make sure that everyone aware of the initial incident is also made aware that it is not according to policy and that official action has been taken - while still respecting the privacy of individual attendees. When speaking to individuals (those who are aware of the incident, but were not involved with the incident) about the incident it is a good idea to keep the details out.

Depending on the incident, Librecast may decide to make one or more public announcements. If necessary, this will be done with a short announcement on all Librecast public channels.

This procedure has been adapted from the Ada Initiative’s guide titled “Conference anti-harassment/Responding to Reports” and Otter Tech work on the Pycon USA 2018 Code of Conduct.